Displacing whiteness makes a unique contribution to the study of race dominance. Whiteness studies is the study of the structures that produce white privilege, the examination of what whiteness is when analyzed as a race, a culture, and a source of systemic racism, and the exploration of other social phenomena generated by the societal compositions, perceptions and group behaviours of white people. Few whiteness studies texts have been published in rhetoric. Making whites from the dark side 375 and consequences of white racism in hopes of abolishing whiteness as a construct for inequality. Environmental education resources to commemorate earth days 50th anniversary. Holmes university of minnesota the publics approval of the president plays a critical role in determining the presidents power and policymaking success. Hip hop has an obligation to combine social protest, music, and modes of cultural. How did immigrants to the united states come to see themse. How antiwhite rhetoric is fueling white nationalism. In the rhetoric field, there is an intellectual debate about aristotles definition of rhetoric. Useful for ap composition students or anyone looking for. Bibliography includes bibliographical references and index.
Anderson examines the strategic presentation of identity in four narratives of religious, sexual, political, and mystical conversions. Rhetoric aims to study the capacities of writers or speakers needed to inform, persuade, or motivate particular audiences in specific situations. Although whiteness studies has been waning as an active research field for the past decade, the contributors to rhetorics of whiteness assert that it hasnt lost its relevancy because racialized whiteness and issues of systemic racism persist in american society and culture today. Reading, writing, and the rhetorics of whiteness routledge studies in rhetoric and communication ryden, wendy, marshall, ian on. What do the understanding rhetoric authors compare a good argument to. An outgrowth of the work of race scholars of color, whiteness studies has. Discusses some of the rhetorical strategies through which whiteness resecures its discursive space and concludes with three aspects of reflexivity that offer directions for future research. The ability to form and defend your own judgments rather than blindly accepting or instantly rejecting what you hear or read. At the vanguard of the study of race and labour in american history, david r. Its theoretical innovations in the analysis of whiteness are integrated with careful, substantive explorations of whiteness on an international, multiracial, crossclass, and gendered terrain. Features of understanding rhetoric, correlated to the. Critical rhetoric and the possibility of the subject.
An analysis of rhetoric from george washington to bill clinton elvin t. Why do they say that complex conversations arent just about right and wrong. Roediger is the author of the nowclassic the wages of whiteness, a study of racism in the development of a white working class in nineteenthcentury america. Bushs second republican party nomination acceptance speech is an intriguing piece of rhetoric that is discussed in this study. When used well and ethically, rhetoric functions to adjust ideas to people and people to ideas bryant, 1953, p. Foundations of whiteness whiteness and beyond philip c wander, judith martin and thomas nakayama sociohistorical foundations of whiteness and. Broad, brian huot, patricia lynne, norbert elliot, edward m. Zeus leonardo defines whiteness as a racial discourse, whereas the.
Mckerrow, professor of rhetoric and communication studies, university of ohio. Why does the campus need a study group on whiteness. Strategic reading investigating texts and analyzing meaning, p. The rhetorical study of whiteness coalesced around thomas k. University of nevada, reno the rhetoric of writing assessment a.
Whiteness studies typically conveyed how the contemporary racial landscape became and continued to be racist. What are the four questions that the audience needs to ask when beginning to look at. A critical autoethnographic tale of a strategic rhetoric. Lecture on main ideas of the whiteness as a strategic rhetoric 2.
Nakayama and krizek 1995 argued that one type of strategic rhetoric of whiteness is in its negative definitions, or in the sense of lacking colorrace that makes it invisible. Like the rhetoric and ideals of the civil rights movement, diversity rhetoric decries discrimination and extols inclusiveness. We conclude with three aspects of reflexivity that offer directions for further research. This mapping of the discursive space, or territory, of whiteness is the first step in the process of exposing whiteness as a rhetorical construction. This work is an investigation into the persuasive techniques inherent in presentations of identity. In intricately textured detail and with passionately mastered analysis, grace elizabeth hale shows how, when faced with the active citizenship of their ex.
Lets take a look at the term rhetorical mode and define each word. The politics of remembrance is a book written by sherrow pinder in which a critical evaluation of whiteness and its impacts on the american society is conducted with an intent to contribute to the nationwide debate on americas past and the roots of racism. Aristotle defines rhetoric as the faculty of observing in any. Catholic social activist dorothy days the long loneliness, political commentator david brocks blinded by the right, deirdre mccloskeys memoir of transgender transformation, crossing, and the wellknown native. Toxic identification, queer vernacular rhetoric, and mediated articulations. Reading, writing, and the rhetorics of whiteness routledge studies in rhetoric and communication. Working toward whiteness left a greater mark on me than any of the other books that i read during that period though. Features of understanding rhetoric, correlated to the writing program administrators wpa outcomes statement. Historians clive webb and charles eagles have called for further research on white supremacy arguing that attention to white supremacist discourse is important both to fully understand and appreciate procivil rights rhetoric in context and to develop a more complex understanding of white supremacist rhetoric. This characteristic of whiteness is unique to its discursive construction and must be understood as a part of its power and force.
The problems and politics of identity for contemporary public address. North america as we know it today represents a joining of 11 dominate. Rhetorical strategies are also called rhetorical modes. Their hope is that particularizing white experience and exposing whiteness as a cultural construction. Philosophical methods are well suited for unpacking the political, ontological, and epistemological conditions that foster racism and hold white supremacy in place. Studies how does one become white through discourse. Foundations of whiteness whiteness and beyond philip c wander, judith martin and thomas nakayama sociohistorical. The strange journey from ellis island to the suburbs. The diversity rationale in political context daniel ibsen morales introduction the scholarly discourse regarding affirmative action in higher education has gone awry, becoming shrillr and calcified. A strategic rhetoric, thomas nakayama and robert krizek examine the construction of whiteness 1 as the invisible, yet influential, center of racial politics in contemporary western society. Whiteness is a standpoint, a place from which white people look at themselves, at others, at society. Making whiteness is a profoundly important work that explains how and why whiteness came to be such a crucial, embattledand distortingcomponent of twentiethcentury american identity.
The readers goals are addressing the key strategic challenge ques tion, undertaking the second kind of exercise and strategic project and effectively analysing the case studies. The process of identifying your goals and then determining how best to achieve. The rhetoric of writing assessment uses strategic variations of rhetorical theory to. I really thought this one was just okay, but didnt feel like it should get lower marks just because i was not particularly interested in it. On black panther, afrofuturism, and astroblackness. If whiteness is no longer the default and is to be treated as an identity even, soon, a minority then perhaps it is time white people considered the disadvantages of being a. Ten examples of antiwhite rhetoric at colleges december 29, 2016, spencer irvine, 10 comments white privilege is an oftused term at colleges nowadays, which alleges that white americans have an internal privilege complex that demeans other ethnicities and races by exerting supremacy. Communication scholars have often overlooked the importance of whiteness as an influence in their research. Potter towson university, towson, maryland, usa nakayama and krizecks essay, a strategic rhetoric of whiteness offers an understanding of whiteness as cultural praxis operating beyond the narrow understanding of mere skin color. Memory and the rhetoric of white supremacy asu digital. Discursive strategy that maintains whiteness as normal and others as different. The issues of blackness and whiteness in america are topical. In intricately textured detail and with passionately mastered analysis, grace elizabeth hale shows how, when faced with the active citizenship of their exslaves after the civil war, white.
Presidential studies quarterly june 2002lim five trends in presidential rhetoric five trends in presidential rhetoric. Reading, writing, and the rhetorics of whiteness routledge. Lim nuffield college, university of oxford several political scientists have argued that the presidential recourse to public rhetoric as a. I will argue the reason the comic frame emerges from the texts is because there is a societal mandate for the comic frame. What is rhetorical leadership my perspective statement. In my work i researched the origin and the ideology of whiteness in the novel caucasia by danzy senna, and two critical articles. Nov 27, 2016 if whiteness is no longer the default and is to be treated as an identity even, soon, a minority then perhaps it is time white people considered the disadvantages of being a race. The development of whiteness studies over the last decade has been welcomed by some, and noted with trepidation by others. Whiteness and racialized ethnic groups in the united states. We then discuss some of the rhetorical strategies through which whiteness resecures its discursive space. The mirage of an unmarked whiteness the making and. Your use of this heinonline pdf indicates your acceptance. In toward a new rhetoric of difference, stephanie l.
Nov 15, 2019 nakayama and krizek 1995 argued that one type of strategic rhetoric of whiteness is in its negative definitions, or in the sense of lacking colorrace that makes it invisible. The relationship between the writing situation, the three basic rhetorical appeals, and the use of discourse is very important to creating and delivering an effective speech, report, or argument. Basic rhetoric and writing strategy rhetoric is generally defined as the art of persuasion. Discusses some of the rhetorical strategies through which whiteness resecures its discursive space and concludes with three aspects of reflexivity that offer directions for. The rise in managerial rhetoric about diversity is particularly interesting because it occurs at a time when support for civil rights appears to be waning and rules banning affirmative action are gaining legitimacy. This post was guestwritten by president decatur in light of media reports in recent days, several alumni, parents, and other friends of the college have asked me a series of questions.
Introduction when i teach heart of darkness, i often introduce students to chinua achebes wellknown an image of africa, an essay in which achebe denounces conrad as a thoroughgoing racist and dismisses his liberal ideology with its effective erasure of africa. Since american political rhetoric is the focus of this study, it will be defined and the history of it will be accounted for. Read whiteness and racialized ethnic groups in the united. Whiteness studies, hip hop pedagogies, and the rhetorics of white. More and more prominent minds tell that race is artificially constructed illusion that means nothing in real. Clearly, american society isnt as colorblind as people would like to believe. Rhetoric as the art of judgment would mean the rhetor discerns the available means of persuasion with a. Roediger is the author of the nowclassic the wages of whiteness, a study of the role of racism in the development of the white working class in nineteenthcentury america. Rhetorical strategies free download as powerpoint presentation.
Whiteness studies is the study of the structures that produce white privilege, the examination of. While thinkers and scholars have debated the merits of various rhetorical strategies over the past few thousand years, some basic principles have remained constant since the earliest greek philosophers began studying oration and argumentation. As a media event, the hashtag and its strategic uses offer a roadmap for more effectively countering the extreme right in the digital public sphere. Cant you and the campus move beyond obsessions with race and diversity. A critical autoethnographic tale of a strategic rhetoric jennifer e. The process of identifying your goals and then determining how best to achieve them. Representation of whiteness in media by danielle delbert on prezi.
Towards a bibliography of critical whiteness studies philosophy and whiteness. This is a classic theme in critical race theory, that people of color carry a burden of representation that white people do not. Introduction thomas k nakayama and judith n martin whiteness as the communication of social identity reflections on critical whiteness studies parker c johnson part one. How antiwhite rhetoric is fueling white nationalism white people are being askedor pushedto take stock of their whiteness and identify with it more. Misuse of discourse based on audience and situation can be embarrassing for the speaker or confusing for the audience. In this essay, we explore the territory of whiteness. Power point about the rhetorical strategies of writing. The study, almost an ethnography of hmong american students at a highly ranked high school in madison, wisconsin, seems to have been well done and come to interesting conclusions along with useful connections to other reputable literature. Kerschbaum establishes a critical niche, a new front line, in our ongoing efforts to understand how our students can make use of difference in their livesespecially as difference continues to thicken at every turn of their lived experience both in the writing classroom and out. In working toward whiteness, he continues that history into the twentieth century.
Slavery as a system of property facilitated the merger of white identity and. The other is more practical, with an emphasis on knowing how to construct a good strategy. Postracial hauntings in popular culture, social media, and education, contributors reveal how identifications with racialized whiteness continue to manifest themselves in american culture. At the vanguard of the study of race and labor in american history, david r. Remote work advice from the largest allremote company. Plessys arrest was arranged as part of a strategy that included the. The identity politics of whiteness the new york times. I will argue from the intersection we see the emergence of the comic frame as a homology that links the disparate texts of obama and tds. Postracial hauntings in popular culture, social media, and education, contributors reveal how identifications with racialized whiteness. Strikingly, this shift in rhetoric undermines what was once the core of antiracist efforts. These strategies or modes provide writers with a way to structure or analyze essays and paragraphs.
According to enos 1996, political rhetoric can be defined by six different elements. Diversity rhetoric and the managerialization of law. Some believe that aristotle defines rhetoric in on rhetoric as the art of persuasion, while others think he defines it as the art of judgment. Pdf this chapter continues a practice introduced by critical. Dec 21, 2016 although whiteness studies has been waning as an active research field for the past decade, the contributors to rhetorics of whiteness assert that it hasnt lost its relevancy because racialized whiteness and issues of systemic racism persist in american society and culture today. Explores the territory of whiteness in order to map the discursive space it occupies, as the first step in the process of exposing whiteness as a rhetorical construction. This section will focus on the use of rhetorical modes to build paragraphs and essays. Drawing on kenneth burkes dialectic of constitutions, anderson analyzes conversion narratives to illustrate how the authors of these autobiographical texts describe dramatic changes in their identities as a means of influencing. Reynaldo anderson is an associate professor of communication and chair of the humanities department at harrisstowe state university in saint louis missouri and serves as an executive board member of the missouri arts council.
Treating people equally has given way to making all of us ambassadors for our race. Scholars and pundits have thus devoted a large amount of. The mirage of an unmarked whiteness, the making and unmaking of whiteness, birgit brander rasmussen, eric klinenberg, irene j. Rhetoric offers an explanatory framework for how and why communication fails or succeeds, as well as practical domain knowledge for how to design and effect sound communication strategies, while discourse analysis is a set of approaches and methods to analyzing realworld language use discourse. Fishers narrative paradigm is used as a rhetorical analysis tool to explore these. The coes whiteness class would additionally address how communities of. Nakayama and krizecks essay, a strategic rhetoric of whiteness offers an understanding of whiteness as cultural praxis operating beyond the narrow understanding of mere skin color. The role of rhetoric in content strategy dean froslie 30 sep 20 when we create content, its easy to be swept up by value propositions, brand standards, style guides, content types and industry jargon. While thinkers and scholars have debated the merits of various rhetorical strategies over the past few thousand years, some basic principles have remained constant. While ive had to stop and think about other sources that i was working off of as i go through and backfill books ive read into goodreads, this book never left the forefront of my mind. He is the past chair of the black caucus of the national communication association nca. Nakayama and krizeks 1995 whiteness as strategic rhetoric is a seminal article. Revisioning strategic communication through rhetoric and.
670 678 1050 344 919 863 1081 380 371 4 450 597 386 986 690 1107 1151 1178 660 424 63 1193 735 1501 1163 59 7 277 1280 424 1123 1069 1291 1055 487 180